Failure to Prove Consequential Damages

by Kent Holland | Apr 15, 2025 | Newsletter Article

Owner established that its contractor breached its contract by failing to complete and/or properly perform bathroom tile work in a house being built.  The Owner sought compensatory as well as consequential damages allegedly caused by construction delays resulting from...

One-sided Arbitration Clause Unenforceable

by Kent Holland | Apr 14, 2025 | Newsletter Article

An arbitration clause that gave one party sole discretion in deciding whether to arbitrate a claim was unenforceable.  A district court granted contractor’s motion to compel arbitation but this was reversed on appeal because of the one-sided nature of the clause...

Contractor Forfeited Right to Indemnity from Insurance Carrier

by Kent Holland | Apr 14, 2025 | Newsletter Article

Where Insured contractor settled a claim against it by its owner client, the insurance carrier declined to cover the settlement as “damages”.  In a lawsuit against the carrier by the contractor, a court found the carrier had no duty to indemnify the contractor for the...

General Contractor Claim against Subcontractor Barred by Statute of Limitations applicable to Contract Claims, but Permitted under Negligence Statute of Limitations

by Kent Holland | Feb 19, 2025 | Newsletter Article

A general contractor (GC) was sued by a homeowner because the house burned because of alleged deficiencies in a subcontractor’s masonry work on a fireplace.  The GC lost a judgment of $1.2 million at arbitration.  The subcontractor declined to join the arbitration...

CGL Policy not required to indemnify a judgment against a general contractor – Professional Liability Exclusion and the “Your Work” Exclusions Applied

by Kent Holland | Feb 19, 2025 | Newsletter Article

Where a swimming pool construction contractor built a multi-million dollar “floating floor pool, it designed a system based on information found on YouTube.  When completed, the pool floor wouldn’t raise evenly.  It jammed inside the pool shell and each time it was...

Condo Owners Sue Condo Association for Breach of Contract for Failing to Repair Defective Foundations to their Units (6 year statute of limitations applied)

by Kent Holland | Feb 19, 2025 | Newsletter Article

Where the foundations under several condominium style townhouses settled and caused damage, the unit owners sued the condo association for failing to do necessary repairs.  The court dismissed the tort claim that asserted that the foundations were negligently...